CREATE AN ACCOUNT
LOG IN

Property Underwriting

A guide to key risks in Washington state: fire, wildfire and earthquakes.


Help Center

Self-serve articles on how to use our products. Available 24/7. 

Commercial Property

Information on Loss Costs, policy rating and assessment tools 


InsuranceEDGE

Weekly newsletter covering the P&C industry, curated by our experts. 

Protection Classes

The evaluation process explained from start to finish.


WSRB Blog

News on emerging risks as well as our latest products. 

Library

In-depth content on essential insurance topics.


Industry Toolkit

Links to help you work smarter and serve your customers.  

Why Sprinkler Systems Fail

July 17, 2018

In the insurance industry, we consider the automatic sprinkler system one of the world’s greatest inventions. The first modern system was designed and installed in 1812, and by 1890, automated sprinkler technology more or less resembled the systems in use today.

An automatic fire sprinkler system headAutomatic fire sprinkler systems can save property and lives,
but only if they're working properly

For over 100 years, WSRB has been evaluating and recommending fire insurance rate credit for automatic sprinkler systems. When properly designed, installed and maintained, these systems are an extremely effective way to protect buildings and contents from fire damage. They’re also a good way to save money. Automatic sprinkler system credit can shave up to 50% off advisory loss costs.

Several studies have determined their effectiveness, and this has been backed up by insurance loss data. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), the primary source of sprinkler installation standards, has conducted a number of studies over the years. Factory Mutual, public fire organizations and others have also studied automatic sprinklers.

Studies indicate that automatic sprinkler systems are effective at controlling and/or suppressing nearly 90% of fires in the buildings where they are installed.

 

Related:
WSRB's Essential Guide to Commercial Property Risk Assessment

 

What happens the other 10% of the time?

More often than not, systems fail to work because the control valves are turned off. This factor accounts for over 50% of sprinkler failures.

Other factors include lack of maintenance, lack of coverage resulting in large non-sprinklered areas, and sprinkler systems that are not designed appropriately for the occupancy (which often features high-piled storage or flammable liquids). Studies show each of these factors account for 5 to 15% of sprinkler failures.

Manual intervention is another cause. This occurs when systems are prematurely turned off, by on-site personnel or the fire department. Failures can also happen if anything is installed that obstructs the sprinkler heads. Manual interventions and obstructions account for up to 18% of sprinkler failures.

What WSRB looks for in a sprinkler system

When a WSRB Commercial Property Analyst surveys a building to establish advisory loss costs, they pay special attention to the automatic fire sprinkler system, if one is present. First, they’ll go into the sprinkler riser (or control) room to verify the system is turned on, and is monitored by a central station or securely locked in place. The same goes for control valves on the outside of the building.

Next, they’ll look for proper testing and maintenance records. Typically, these are produced during an annual inspection performed by a licensed sprinkler contractor. They will also determine the design of the sprinkler system based on plans or hydraulic design information in the riser room.

As our analyst walks through the building, they look for non-sprinklered areas. Has a large tool room been added without sprinkler protection? Is there a non-sprinklered attic space? Fires can spread in areas with inadequate sprinkler coverage.

Finally, they look at what material is present and how it’s being stored. The higher the combustibility of the product and/or the more product stored in one place, the more water will be needed to contain or extinguish a fire. Is the sprinkler system designed to do this? If the occupant or building has changed since it was installed, the system may no longer be adequate.

 

Related:
Commercial Buildings: Top 10 Risk Issues

 

While extremely effective, fire sprinkler systems aren’t perfect. The factors WSRB uses to determine the amount of credit a sprinkler system should get are the same factors that determine whether that system will operate as needed. The end goal is the same, to save property and lives.

If you have a customer who wants to maximize the benefits of their sprinkler system, make sure they have a licensed sprinkler contractor perform a maintenance and testing inspection on at least an annual basis. Then, login to the member section of our site to request an inspection. Inspections are included with your WSRB subscription, and they’re a good way to help customers gain credit, or show them what they need to do to make sure their sprinkler system will protect them as effectively as possible.


Robert Lacy, WSRB's Vice President, Inspection Services & Professional Development, oversees our team of commercial property analysts as they produce advisory loss costs, commercial property reports and evaluate automatic fire sprinkler systems. He is involved in the annual evaluation of our loss cost levels and ensuring we are current on coding and rating issues for commercial property. He also works to encourage continual professional development for all WSRB employees.

Guy-reading-insuranceEDGE

InsuranceEDGE


Like our blog? Check out InsuranceEDGE. We curate the week’s must-read stories from top industry sources. You stay informed and save time.

START READING

You May Also Like

These stories on commercial property risk

Sign up for our blog